Altri feedback sulle alternative a MinIO, ora definitivamente abbandonato nella versione open source, da Hacker News.

Un confronto tra le principali alternative (vedi anche miei post precedenti):

First off, I don't think there is anything wrong with MinIO closing down its open source. There are simply too many people globally who use open source without being willing to pay for it. I started testing various alternatives a few months ago, and I still believe RustFS will emerge as the winner after MinIO's exit. I evaluated Garage, SeaweedFS, Ceph, and RustFS. Here are my conclusions:

  1. RustFS and SeaweedFS are the fastest in the object storage field.

  2. The installation for Garage and SeaweedFS is more complex compared to RustFS.

  3. The RustFS console is the most convenient and user-friendly.

  4. Ceph is too difficult to use; I wouldn't dare deploy it without a deep understanding of the source code.

Although many people criticize RustFS, suggesting its CLA might be "bait," I don't think such a requirement is excessive for open source software, as it helps mitigate their own legal risks.

Furthermore, Milvus gave RustFS a very high official evaluation. Based on technical benchmarks and other aspects, I believe RustFS will ultimately win.

https://milvus.io/blog/evaluating-rustfs-as-a-viable-s3-compatible-object-storage-backend-for-milvus.md

Un po' di promozione dall'autore di SeaweedFS:

I work on SeaweedFS since 2011, and full time since 2025.

SeaweedFS was started as a learning project and evolves along the way, getting ideas from papers for Facebook Haystack, Google Colossus, Facebook Tectonics. With its distributed append-only storage, it naturally fits object store. Sorry to see MinIO went away. SeaweedFS learned a lot from it. Some S3 interface code was copied from MinIO when it was still Apache 2.0 License. AWS S3 APIs are fairly complicated. I am trying to replicate as much as possible.

Some recent developments:

  • Run "weed mini -dir=xxx", it will just work. Nothing else to setup.

  • Added Table Bucket and Iceberg Catalog.

  • Added admin UI